Home / Mystery/Thriller / Buried Truths / Chapter Five: The Price of Silence
Chapter Five: The Price of Silence
Author: Beloved Elizabeth
last update Last Updated: 2024-12-27 10:55:13

The rain had begun to fall heavily, the sound of it hammering against the roof of Sheriff Will Baker’s house, creating a constant rhythm in the otherwise quiet evening.

Inside, the air smelled of coffee and old wood, the scent of familiarity to Vera, who had lived in this house for years.

She had grown up here after her parents’ death, and even now, it felt like a place of both refuge and prison. The shadows seemed to cling to the walls as if they held memories she couldn’t escape.

She had always known her uncle Sheriff Will Baker as a man of few words—especially when it came to the past. He was the town’s protector, its pillar of strength.

But tonight, something had shifted. His words, the cryptic promise he’d made, had hit her like a slap in the face.

She couldn’t let it go.She sat at the kitchen table, the hot mug of coffee in front of her growing cold as she waited for him to return from his patrol. The quiet creaking of the old house seemed amplified in the stillness, but her mind was anything but quiet.

Vera knew that the sheriff had been hiding something—he had always been secretive, always distant about certain things, but this was different.

The promise he had made, the one that kept him from revealing what he knew about Lily’s death, had set something off in her.

What could be so damaging, so dangerous, that her uncle would rather stay silent than help her find out what happened to Lily?

Her thoughts were interrupted by the sound of the front door opening. Sheriff Baker entered, his heavy boots leaving muddy footprints on the floor as he shrugged off his coat and hung it on the rack by the door.

He looked worn, his face drawn with a mixture of exhaustion and something else that Vera couldn’t place.

“Vera,” he said, his voice steady but with a hint of something softer, something that almost sounded like regret.

“I didn’t expect you to still be here.”She stood up, pushing her chair back with a quiet scrape, her eyes locking onto his. “I’m not going anywhere until we talk. About what you said earlier. About the promise. What did you mean by that?”

Sheriff Baker froze for a moment, his hand still on the doorframe. He didn’t meet her gaze, his eyes trained on the ground. The silence between them thickened, the weight of her question pressing against him like a vice.

When he finally looked up, his eyes were darker, his expression unreadable.

“I meant exactly what I said, Vera,” he replied, his voice low, each word measured, careful. “There are things you don’t know. Things you’re better off not knowing.”

Vera felt her pulse quicken. She knew he was avoiding the answer, but she wasn’t about to back down. “But I need to know, Uncle. For Lily. For myself. What happened to her? And why are you keeping secrets? Why can’t you tell me the truth?”

Sheriff Baker sighed heavily, rubbing the back of his neck in frustration. He was a man used to bearing the burden of his responsibilities alone, but now, it felt as if that weight was suffocating him.

He took a step forward, his face hardening as if he were preparing to fight against something far bigger than the conversation they were having.

“Vera…” he began, his voice shaking slightly.

“You think you want the truth. But there are truths that can break you. You’re not ready for what you’ll find. And I made a promise. A promise to someone, a long time ago. You wouldn’t understand, but that promise… it’s the reason you’re standing here today, it’s the reason you got to go to school, why you had everything you needed after your parents died.”

Vera’s chest tightened, the confusion growing. “What does that have to do with Lily? With what happened to her?”

“I can’t tell you everything,” Sheriff Baker said, his tone so firm it felt like a wall being built between them. He crossed the room, moving toward the kitchen window and staring out into the rain-soaked yard. “

There are things you’ll never understand, no matter how hard you try. Some things are better left in the past.”

Vera took a step closer, the urgency in her voice rising. “You’re telling me you’re going to keep this from me? After everything, after Lily, after the years of searching? You’re not going to help me?”

Sheriff Baker turned to face her, his eyes cold, unreadable. “I’ve already done more than I should, Vera. There’s only so much I can say without breaking the promise I made.”

Vera was silent for a moment, digesting his words, but it didn’t make sense. The promise. Her entire life, she’d never known there was a secret so dark, so significant, that it had shaped everything about her existence.

She had grown up in this house, raised by a man who loved her but had always kept a certain distance. And now, she was learning that everything she thought she knew was a lie.

“I don’t understand,” Vera said softly, her voice strained. “What do you mean? What did this person do for me? Who are they? Why can’t I know? Why are you protecting them?”

Sheriff Baker’s jaw clenched, and for a moment, he looked as though he might break. But the moment passed, and the walls went up again.

“You went to school thanks to that person I promised to never reveal,” he said, his voice barely above a whisper. “You have what you have because of them. Knowing who they are… it will only hurt you, Vera. Trust me on that.”

Vera felt the sting of his words like a slap. “Why?” Her voice cracked, the frustration boiling over. “Why can’t I know the truth?”

Her uncle’s eyes softened for the briefest of moments, and there was a flicker of something—regret, perhaps, or guilt. But it was gone before she could make sense of it.

“Because it’s not your burden to carry,” Sheriff Baker said quietly, almost as if speaking to himself. “Some things are better left buried, even if it means losing everything.”

Vera felt the coldness in his words seep into her chest. Her entire life had been shaped by this man’s decisions, and now she was learning that those decisions were based on a secret so dangerous that it threatened to unravel everything she knew about her past.

The answer she was looking for—about Lily, about her parents, about the promise—was slipping further from her grasp.

“Then I’ll figure it out on my own,” Vera said, the determination in her voice masking the hurt that threatened to spill over. “I’ll find out what really happened to Lily, and I’ll do it without you.”

Sheriff Baker didn’t reply.

He didn’t have to. The finality in his silence was enough.

Vera turned and walked away, her mind a whirlwind of questions that couldn’t be answered. She had come here for answers, but all she had gotten was more confusion.

Her uncle’s promise, the truth he was so desperately trying to keep from her—it felt like a weight she couldn’t shake.

As she stepped out into the rain-soaked night, she realized one thing: there was no going back. Whatever secrets Sheriff Baker was hiding, whatever promises he had made, they were now part of her story too.

She wasn’t going to stop until she uncovered them, no matter what the cost.

She would dig deeper. And she would not rest until she found the truth, no matter how dangerous it became.

Related Chapters

  • Buried Truths   Chapter Six:The Weight of Silence

    …..Mrs Rachel Montgomery houseVera and Elliot visited Rachel. Rachel was the friend of Elliot’s mum ,older but not frail.She greeted them at the door with a reserved smile. Her gray hair was neatly tucked under a soft scarf, and there was a quiet strength in her eyes that made Elliot both uneasy and comforted at once. Her home, much like her, hadn’t changed in years. The same overstuffed chairs, the same faint smell of tea, the same porcelain figurines on display. Time had simply passed it by.“Well, look who’s here,” Rachel said, her voice warm but weary as she embraced Elliot. He hadn’t expected the hug, but it was comforting, just as he remembered. “It’s been too long, Elliot.”Vera stood back, nodding politely. “Thank you for seeing us, Mrs. Montgomery.”Rachel’s eyes flickered to Vera before she gave a tight smile. “It’s not a problem. I’m just surprised to see you both together after all this time. Come in, sit down. I’ve got some tea ready.” Her tone was casual, but her eyes

  • Buried Truths   Chapter Seven: Beneath the Surface

    Elliot Carter and Vera Larkin sat in the dusty back room of the old library in Harrison Creek, a town that once felt like home but now seemed more like a prison of secrets. The air was thick with the scent of mildew and age-old paper, the quiet sound of their breath the only thing breaking the heavy silence. It had been weeks since they first began their search into Lily Rose’s disappearance, and each piece of the puzzle they uncovered led them further down a path they weren’t sure they wanted to follow.Tonight was different. Tonight, they were on the brink of uncovering the truth. But the truth, as they were beginning to understand, was darker than either of them had ever imagined.Elliot’s hands trembled slightly as he flipped through a medical journal he had taken from his father’s office, its yellowed pages revealing far more than he had ever hoped to find. Robert Carter, his father, had been hiding something. Something big. And the more Elliot read, the more horrifying it becam

  • Buried Truths   Chapter Eight: The masked hand

    The hospital was unnervingly quiet. The soft hum of machines, the distant rustle of nurses’ uniforms, and the occasional murmur of conversations were the only sounds that broke the stillness. Elliot walked beside Vera, his eyes downcast, trying to contain the hurricane of emotions swirling inside him. He could barely keep his thoughts straight. His world had been turned upside down, and now, he was walking straight into the eye of the storm.“Are you sure you’re ready for this?” Vera asked, her voice soft but laced with concern. They stopped in front of the door to Robert’s room, the sterile white walls pressing in on them.Elliot didn’t answer right away. His gaze was locked on the door. He had to do this. He had to confront the man who had destroyed so many lives—including his own. “I’m ready,” he said at last, his voice hollow.Vera hesitated but didn’t press further. “I’ll go to Dr. Mark’s office, and you… you go to your dad.”Elliot nodded, his throat tightening. “I’m not leavin

  • Buried Truths   Chapter Nine:The snake beneath the grass

    The office of Dr. Mark was eerily calm. A large, polished wooden desk stood in the center of the room, papers neatly stacked, and medical books lining the shelves. The soft hum of the fluorescent lights above was the only sound breaking the stillness. Dr. Mark’s office was a sanctuary of order,a stark contrast to the chaos of what Elliot had just witnessed. Vera sat quietly across from Elliot, her hand resting gently on his shoulder. Her presence was a steadying force, but she could see that Elliot was struggling to hold it all together. The silence between them was thick, filled with unspoken questions, but neither of them knew how to begin unraveling the truth that was just out of reach. Elliot had been silent since they left Robert’s room, his mind racing with the horror of what he had learned and the flood of emotions that came with it. His father’s terror, his outburst of anger, and the truth he had uncovered in the journal,it was all too much to process. “Elliot,” Vera’

  • Buried Truths   Chapter Ten:The ties that bind

    Late one evening, as they pored over the brittle pages of old documents in the dimly lit library, Elliot’s phone rang, its shrill tone cutting through the silence like a knife. The night was thick with the kind of silence that only comes when the world is asleep, and the moon hung like a quiet witness in the sky. Elliot and Vera sat outside his house, the cool evening air wrapping around them, mingling with the faint smell of old pine and damp earth. The porch light flickered softly, casting long shadows over the two of them, but they didn’t speak at first. There was something almost sacred in the stillness, as if the weight of the past hung between them, too heavy to disturb. Elliot broke the silence. His voice was quieter than usual, almost fragile. “Vera… I don’t know how to thank you for staying with me. For helping me find Lily. I couldn’t have done this without you.” Vera sat a little straighter, her heart squeezing at the sincerity in his words. She’d been by his side t

  • Buried Truths    Chapter Eleven:The web unravels

    Elliot’s confrontation with his father was only the beginning. The more he dug, the more dangerous the people around him became. In the weeks that followed, anonymous threats escalated. People in the town who had once been friendly turned cold, refusing to speak to him, giving him sidelong glances as if they knew something he didn’t. Elliot knew that Robert wasn’t the only one involved. There were others in Harrison Creek—others who had helped him bury the truth. The problem was figuring out who they were. Vera, too, had her own share of dangers to deal with. She’d received anonymous warnings, and her sources had gone silent. Yet despite the threats, she remained committed to the investigation. But Elliot and Vera were in too deep now. Every door they knocked on, every person they spoke to, only led to more questions. The town, it seemed, was ready to do anything to keep its dark secrets buried. Elliot stepped into Mrs. Rachel Montgomery’s home again. The faint scent of aged w

  • Buried Truths   Chapter 12: The journey to the facility

    The fog had swallowed the road, shrouding everything in a thick, oppressive mist as Elliot and Vera drove deeper into the mountains. The car’s headlights struggled to cut through the swirling white, casting eerie shadows along the narrow, winding path. The silence in the car felt suffocating, broken only by the steady hum of the engine and the occasional crackle of static from the radio, which seemed to fight the weight of the atmosphere around them. Elliot’s heart pounded in his chest. Every mile they drove toward the facility felt like a step closer to a truth he wasn’t sure he was ready to confront. Vera, sitting beside him, had said little, her face etched with the same uneasy anticipation. The questions they had about the experiments, his father’s involvement, Lily’s disappearance were all starting to feel like more than just echoes from the past. The truth they were about to uncover was going to change everything. “We’re almost there,” Elliot muttered, more to himself than t

  • Buried Truths   PROLOGUE

    The Night Lily Rose DisappearedThe night was quiet, too quiet for Harrison Creek. A dense fog had rolled in, swallowing the streets and casting the small town in an eerie, suffocating haze. The cold air hung heavy, laced with the smell of damp earth and decaying leaves. The sound of the creek, usually a gentle murmur, was strangely absent, as though the water itself had been frozen in time. The old mill, once the lifeblood of the town, loomed at the edge of the fog, its crumbling brick structure barely visible in the distance. The creek flowed dark and silent beneath it, its waters disturbed only by the occasional ripple of something that didn’t belong. In the dim light, Dr. Robert Carter stood at the water’s edge, his breath coming in shallow, controlled bursts. His back was to the town, his eyes fixed on the shadowy form of Lily Rose as she stood just beyond the trees, her figure barely visible in the thick fog. She was trembling, her clothes soaked through with the wetness

Latest Chapter

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter 12: The journey to the facility

    The fog had swallowed the road, shrouding everything in a thick, oppressive mist as Elliot and Vera drove deeper into the mountains. The car’s headlights struggled to cut through the swirling white, casting eerie shadows along the narrow, winding path. The silence in the car felt suffocating, broken only by the steady hum of the engine and the occasional crackle of static from the radio, which seemed to fight the weight of the atmosphere around them. Elliot’s heart pounded in his chest. Every mile they drove toward the facility felt like a step closer to a truth he wasn’t sure he was ready to confront. Vera, sitting beside him, had said little, her face etched with the same uneasy anticipation. The questions they had about the experiments, his father’s involvement, Lily’s disappearance were all starting to feel like more than just echoes from the past. The truth they were about to uncover was going to change everything. “We’re almost there,” Elliot muttered, more to himself than t

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Eleven:The web unravels

    Elliot’s confrontation with his father was only the beginning. The more he dug, the more dangerous the people around him became. In the weeks that followed, anonymous threats escalated. People in the town who had once been friendly turned cold, refusing to speak to him, giving him sidelong glances as if they knew something he didn’t. Elliot knew that Robert wasn’t the only one involved. There were others in Harrison Creek—others who had helped him bury the truth. The problem was figuring out who they were. Vera, too, had her own share of dangers to deal with. She’d received anonymous warnings, and her sources had gone silent. Yet despite the threats, she remained committed to the investigation. But Elliot and Vera were in too deep now. Every door they knocked on, every person they spoke to, only led to more questions. The town, it seemed, was ready to do anything to keep its dark secrets buried. Elliot stepped into Mrs. Rachel Montgomery’s home again. The faint scent of aged w

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Ten:The ties that bind

    Late one evening, as they pored over the brittle pages of old documents in the dimly lit library, Elliot’s phone rang, its shrill tone cutting through the silence like a knife. The night was thick with the kind of silence that only comes when the world is asleep, and the moon hung like a quiet witness in the sky. Elliot and Vera sat outside his house, the cool evening air wrapping around them, mingling with the faint smell of old pine and damp earth. The porch light flickered softly, casting long shadows over the two of them, but they didn’t speak at first. There was something almost sacred in the stillness, as if the weight of the past hung between them, too heavy to disturb. Elliot broke the silence. His voice was quieter than usual, almost fragile. “Vera… I don’t know how to thank you for staying with me. For helping me find Lily. I couldn’t have done this without you.” Vera sat a little straighter, her heart squeezing at the sincerity in his words. She’d been by his side t

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Nine:The snake beneath the grass

    The office of Dr. Mark was eerily calm. A large, polished wooden desk stood in the center of the room, papers neatly stacked, and medical books lining the shelves. The soft hum of the fluorescent lights above was the only sound breaking the stillness. Dr. Mark’s office was a sanctuary of order,a stark contrast to the chaos of what Elliot had just witnessed. Vera sat quietly across from Elliot, her hand resting gently on his shoulder. Her presence was a steadying force, but she could see that Elliot was struggling to hold it all together. The silence between them was thick, filled with unspoken questions, but neither of them knew how to begin unraveling the truth that was just out of reach. Elliot had been silent since they left Robert’s room, his mind racing with the horror of what he had learned and the flood of emotions that came with it. His father’s terror, his outburst of anger, and the truth he had uncovered in the journal,it was all too much to process. “Elliot,” Vera’

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Eight: The masked hand

    The hospital was unnervingly quiet. The soft hum of machines, the distant rustle of nurses’ uniforms, and the occasional murmur of conversations were the only sounds that broke the stillness. Elliot walked beside Vera, his eyes downcast, trying to contain the hurricane of emotions swirling inside him. He could barely keep his thoughts straight. His world had been turned upside down, and now, he was walking straight into the eye of the storm.“Are you sure you’re ready for this?” Vera asked, her voice soft but laced with concern. They stopped in front of the door to Robert’s room, the sterile white walls pressing in on them.Elliot didn’t answer right away. His gaze was locked on the door. He had to do this. He had to confront the man who had destroyed so many lives—including his own. “I’m ready,” he said at last, his voice hollow.Vera hesitated but didn’t press further. “I’ll go to Dr. Mark’s office, and you… you go to your dad.”Elliot nodded, his throat tightening. “I’m not leavin

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Seven: Beneath the Surface

    Elliot Carter and Vera Larkin sat in the dusty back room of the old library in Harrison Creek, a town that once felt like home but now seemed more like a prison of secrets. The air was thick with the scent of mildew and age-old paper, the quiet sound of their breath the only thing breaking the heavy silence. It had been weeks since they first began their search into Lily Rose’s disappearance, and each piece of the puzzle they uncovered led them further down a path they weren’t sure they wanted to follow.Tonight was different. Tonight, they were on the brink of uncovering the truth. But the truth, as they were beginning to understand, was darker than either of them had ever imagined.Elliot’s hands trembled slightly as he flipped through a medical journal he had taken from his father’s office, its yellowed pages revealing far more than he had ever hoped to find. Robert Carter, his father, had been hiding something. Something big. And the more Elliot read, the more horrifying it becam

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Six:The Weight of Silence

    …..Mrs Rachel Montgomery houseVera and Elliot visited Rachel. Rachel was the friend of Elliot’s mum ,older but not frail.She greeted them at the door with a reserved smile. Her gray hair was neatly tucked under a soft scarf, and there was a quiet strength in her eyes that made Elliot both uneasy and comforted at once. Her home, much like her, hadn’t changed in years. The same overstuffed chairs, the same faint smell of tea, the same porcelain figurines on display. Time had simply passed it by.“Well, look who’s here,” Rachel said, her voice warm but weary as she embraced Elliot. He hadn’t expected the hug, but it was comforting, just as he remembered. “It’s been too long, Elliot.”Vera stood back, nodding politely. “Thank you for seeing us, Mrs. Montgomery.”Rachel’s eyes flickered to Vera before she gave a tight smile. “It’s not a problem. I’m just surprised to see you both together after all this time. Come in, sit down. I’ve got some tea ready.” Her tone was casual, but her eyes

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Five: The Price of Silence

    The rain had begun to fall heavily, the sound of it hammering against the roof of Sheriff Will Baker’s house, creating a constant rhythm in the otherwise quiet evening. Inside, the air smelled of coffee and old wood, the scent of familiarity to Vera, who had lived in this house for years. She had grown up here after her parents’ death, and even now, it felt like a place of both refuge and prison. The shadows seemed to cling to the walls as if they held memories she couldn’t escape.She had always known her uncle Sheriff Will Baker as a man of few words—especially when it came to the past. He was the town’s protector, its pillar of strength. But tonight, something had shifted. His words, the cryptic promise he’d made, had hit her like a slap in the face. She couldn’t let it go.She sat at the kitchen table, the hot mug of coffee in front of her growing cold as she waited for him to return from his patrol. The quiet creaking of the old house seemed amplified in the stillness, but her

  • Buried Truths   

    Chapter Four: Secrets in the Shadows

    The shadows seemed to grow longer as Elliot and Vera stood in the clearing, the abandoned mill behind them like an old wound that never healed. They had barely begun their investigation into Lily’s disappearance, but already, their search was leading them down a dark path. There were whispers now—whispers of secrets buried deep, secrets that tied the town’s most respected families to things that should never have been.As they made their way through Harrison Creek, the quiet, sleepy town felt different, heavier, as if every corner hid another piece of the puzzle, one that had been deliberately hidden for far too long.Vera led the way through the winding streets, her face pale but determined. She had lived here her whole life, and even she could no longer ignore the dark undercurrents that had always been present, beneath the calm, everyday life of the town. As they passed the old church, its stained-glass windows shattered and boarded up, Vera’s eyes lingered for a moment too long.